We tried this pizza place for dinner one night and were blown away. The pizza was great! I got their special and my boyfriend got the pesto mozzarella one (can’t remember the names). we lovedddd both of them. they were friendly and quick getting the food out. I would recommend trying to pizza place they do great with mixing flavors!
We were in the area for a soccer tournament and we always look forward to trying local pizza places that we don't have in Northern Ohio. We were not disappointed at all with our Bark-B-Q Chicken Pizza, garlic cheese sticks and salad. The crust had the perfect amount of crisp to it, including the middle square pieces, which can sometimes be floppy. We will definitely return to trying other pizzas when we're in the area again.
I ordered takeout online yesterday for the first time and I have definitely become a long term customer! Everything was great, from the ease of ordering, to the friendliness of the staff, to the quality of the food. I have been trying several different pizza restaurants around the Columbus area since moving here and this is by far my favorite place. The pizza is phenomenal. I love the sauce, flavorful, but not acidic, and not too sweet. The cheese tastes like it is higher quality, and the pepperoni was amazing. I also absolutely loved the thin crust! It has a nice crunch, but is also slightly chewy. It's exactly how I want my pizza to be. Their salad was also very good. Tons of toppings and the house made ranch dressing is very good! It's so much better than prepackaged vinegary ranch that a lot of places use. Overall, I can't wait to come back and try more of the menu!
We are from TN and visiting family in Columbus! They hyped Black Dog Pizzeria up to us and took us there to try it. We ordered the Hound of the Brisketville, the Parmeranian, and 2 choose your toppings…a Chicken Bacon Ranch and a Pickle Pizza, along with pesto cheese sticks. Everything was so delicious! Friendly service, great location and atmosphere, and ample parking. I recommend them 10 out 10 and can’t wait to come back.
I made a “central Ohio pizza tour” booklet/passport thing at the beginning of the year, and when I was researching which places to add, Black Dog Pizzeria kept popping up in everyone’s recommendations. We stopped in on a Saturday, right when they opened, but the door was locked! Sad! But then the clouds parted, angels sang, and the door was opened by none other than the owner himself (I’ll call him Dave, hey Dave!) (yes, I know his name is actually Nick). He was so welcoming and just an all-around awesome dude. Now, don’t go in expecting to sit and eat. We definitely expected that. There’s one table, Tony said we could totally hang out and eat, but I think it’s really just for folks to sit at while waiting for their carry out orders to be ready. That said, there’s a million things to look at on the walls, most of it is art made by customers! Pizza/dog themed art! It’s incredible. And there’s an awesome hand-painted mural that was done by a customer, too. Such a neat way to decorate ???????????? So Dave walked us through the menu, gave us a bit of history about the place as we needlessly deliberated about what to order. See, to give an equal opportunity to each place, we always order a basic pepperoni and cheese. We figure, if you can’t do a classic pep & cheese justice, can you really call yourself a pizza joint?! Well, no worries for black dog. They can DEFINITELY call themselves a pizza joint. This thing came out of the oven smelling divine, like the Sicilians of Italy met up with the cheeseheads of Wisconsin and made a perfect little aromatic potpourri of pizza goodness. Cheese pull: 8/10 Crust: 10/10 Toppings: 10/10 Sauce: 9/10 Ambiance: 15/10 Customer service: 19/10 Overall: yes. Go there. Order everything. See the “oh my goddddd this pizza is amazing” picture below! We liked it so much that we actually went back that same night and got a carry out pie!
